surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Volume 8

Written by Miles Luna, Kerry Shawcross, Eddy Rivas, and Kiersi Burkhart
Directed by Kerry Shawcross, Connor Pickens, Dustin Matthews, and Paula Decanini
Produced under Rooster Teeth


Alternate Title: The One Where Miles and Kerry Escaped the Basement

RWBY, Volume 8.

The first three volumes of RWBY had an inspiring rise stylistically but couldn’t be claimed as a good story, and came with much frustration around certain events. The fourth volume was a downward slope, the fifth a crashing at the bottom, and the sixth a pile of burning wreckage. Surely, we were far past any chance for improvement.

And then came Volume 7. A stunningly, excellently-written season whose only real flaws were not being the prettiest, until the very end. Despite myself, I liked Volume 7 a lot, because there was no doubt of skyrocketing levels of quality. But all the same, the note it ended on did…seem a bit unfavorable. It did end with me enraged and disappointed, nonetheless.

Volume Four was the recovery season. Volume Five was the garbage season. Volume Six was the damage control season, and Volume Seven was the season that almost made it. But if there is a theme to be had for this volume, is is derailment—no one leaves this volume totally happy with the plot or characters. You thought Volume Five was a trainwreck? Wait until you see this one.

Hear me when I say that Volume 8 is almost a step-by-step guide of what not to do with your series, especially after its only truly great entry. Volume 8 is something worse than bad—it’s spiteful. It’s what happens when authors go out of their way to stomp on their own series, and a lot that fans happen to like about it. Let’s get into it.

Here are the counts:

I'm less eager to do this one than I was for Volume 5, no joke. )

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

47 – Volume 7 Finale | Table of Contents | Volume 8

____________________




…I have some bad news, guys. Volume 7 of RWBY is, for the most part, good.

It was always possible in the right hands. )

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

46 – Volume 7, Episodes 11 and 12 | Table of Contents | Volume 7 Final Thoughts

____________________


Alternate Title: The Train Crash Continues

*muffled, behind a veil* The text is staying blue because I’m that pissed off. You just couldn’t fucking let it be, could you? You had to kill him off. I wasn’t even that into him as a character, but by god, you’d better believe I am ready to unleash unholy fury now.

We are still on the twelfth episode of Volume 7, “With Friends Like These”. Qrow has to choose between chasing Tyrian or being with Clover in his dying moments.

The level of spite I have for this is only outmatched by the spite Miles Luna had when writing it. )

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

45 – Volume 7, Episodes 7, 8, 9, and 10 | Table of Contents | 47 – Volume 7 Finale

____________________


Alternate Title: It All Comes Crashing Down

Well, here it is. The part where everything we’ve built is broken down and swept under the rug.

I've been saying this throughout, but this season, it’s been…well, good. Not just ‘less bad than other volumes’, but actually good. Yeah, everything’s ugly, but writing-wise, everything…works. There hasn’t been any filler, the pacing is pretty good, there aren’t any severe missed points… When I was first watching this, I was thinking that Volume 7 needs to get bad, quickly, or it’s gonna make the story of RWBY that much more tragic.

Well, it did get bad quickly, and it did get tragic.

There is no getting over this. I hate this so much. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

44 – Volume 7, Episodes 4, 5, and 6 | Table of Contents | 46 – Volume 7, Episodes 11 and 12

____________________


Alternate Title: It's Still Good!

Well, uh. Huh.

There’s no easy way to say this, guys. Rooster Teeth decided the plot of Volume 7 of RWBY was going to be a recreation (with some dramatic and fantasy elements added) of certain real-world political events with massive consequences for the citizens of certain countries.

I’m…still baffled that they chose this route.

The drama remains consistently good. )

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

43 – Volume 7, Episodes 1, 2, and 3 | Table of Contents | 45 – Episodes 7, 8, 9, and 10

____________________


Alt Title: Gay Bait and American Elections

We had a suspiciously good start last post, barring how goddamn awful everything looked. We also introduced a five-person team of new allies, who I can tell look like they walked directly out of Gen:Lock even though I’ve never watched Gen:Lock. Tyrian killed a socialist.

Don't like where this is going, not one bit. )

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Volume 7

Written by Miles Luna, Kerry Shawcross, Eddy Rivas, and Kiersi Burkhart
Directed by Kerry Shawcross, Connor Pickens, Dustin Matthews, and Paula Decanini
Produced under Rooster Teeth

 

Alternate Title: The One Where Miles and Kerry Were Locked In A Basement

Welcome to Volume 7 of RWBY.

What's the scoop on this one? )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

Volume 6 Finale | Table of Contents | Volume 7

____________________


RWBY Volume 6 is pretty much the only kind of season of RWBY that could’ve followed Volume 5: completely unexpected, jaw-dropping yet underwhelming, and totally incapable of fixing anything.

Let’s start where we usually start, which is story…

This could've been avoided. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

41 – Volume 6, Episodes 8, 9, 10, and 11 | Table of Contents | Volume 6 Final Thoughts

____________________


Alt Title: Holy Fuck

I… There’s no easy way to start this off. It’s the third time I’ve had to cut a post in the middle of an episode, and for that I apologize. I didn’t think they’d pack in ten minutes of giant mecha fight before that big reveal. Um, all the warnings from the prior episode apply.

*sweeping hair back* I just… How to even process this?

Plot points like this don't just require stupidity, they require audacity. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

40 – Volume 6, Episodes 5, 6, and 7 | Table of Contents | 42 – Volume 6 Finale

____________________


We just finished one of the most well-done subplots RWBY has ever had, and now it is time to descend back into hell. Eye-related gore and abuse pop up in this one.

And you thought this seeason had nothing hideous left to shock with? )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

39 – Volume 6, Episodes 3 and 4 | Table of Contents | 40 – Volume 6, Episodes 8, 9, and 11

____________________


Last time, MKG made it clear that annoying someone stronger than you makes it your fault if they kill off your entire species, and made Ozpin into a rapist. This one's got eye-related violence and gore in it.

The good news is that we are entering the short stretch of Volume 6 Episodes that some people actually tend to consider good.

Don't worry, it doesn't last. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

38 – Volume 6, Episodes 2 and 3 | Table of Contents | 40 – Volume 6, Episodes 5, 6 and 7

____________________


Alternate Title: That one. The one I warned you about.

Please be warned that this episode involves a rape, an in-depth discussion of that rape, and a bunch of other completely unpleasant shit including child abuse, child death, suicide attempts...it's real bad.

I have no mouth and I must scream )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

37 – V3 Leak & V6 Short / V6E1 | Table of Contents | 39 – Volume 6, Episodes 3 and 4

____________________


If you haven't been keeping up with the spork so far, now might be a very good time to start reading. We have some Moments(TM) rapidly approaching.

You know when something is so shocking and insane that it kind of short-circuits you? Get ready. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

Volume 5 Retrospective | Table of Contents | Volume 6, Episodes 2 and 3

____________________


Alright. So, Before we move ahead with this, we have to address the leak.

Yes, the leak of the footage that was intended to be part of Volume Three, when Adam menaces and fights with Yang. The one Shane talked about.

Wow! There wasn’t a SINGLE good thing about this episode... )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Volume 6

Written by Miles Luna and Kerry Shawcross,
Directed by Kerry Shawcross and Connor Pickens
Produced under Rooster Teeth

Alternate Title: The One They Couldn’t Save

RWBY, Volume 6.

Where was Rooster Teeth going to go? A volume seemingly conceived as a giant band-aid for prior plot points became, itself, a wound to be bandaged. RWBY, whose fanbase had already cooled as Volume Four received mixed reactions, was now the joke of the internet due to how badly Volume Five had completely screwed it all up. What do they do?

Well, the most futile fucking thing they could, really, but they at least knew where the biggest damage had been done: Adam, hence the short that will start us off.

Volume Six was…umm… Well, it’s bad. It’s definitely not the sharp upswing in quality needed after Volume Five, but nonetheless, we’ll see that some stabs at improvement were made, and then subsequently dragged down with yet more bullshit. But it’s worth going through just for an interesting look at what was going on at Rooster Teeth at the time.

Here’s the counts as they are so far:

To the tune of futile damage control, sing it with me now...! )

 

Profile

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)
surgeworks

March 2024

S M T W T F S
     12
345 678 9
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Nov. 16th, 2025 11:19 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios