surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Final Thoughts: Style | Table of Contents
____________________


Nine years ago today, Monty Oum died of an allergic reaction. Today is a day of mourning for fans of his work, including RWBY.

There’s no sense in waiting. Let’s finish this and heal.
 

Now it's time, to say goodbye )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Final Thoughts: Characters (Part II) | Table of Contents | RWBY Final Thoughts: Legacy

____________________


Before we can finish up on RWBY as a whole, we have to go over style—the ways in which it was presented to the viewer. This one’s important, because it has a lot to do with the parasocial relationship Rooster Teeth have always relied on. Someone new to RWBY and binge-watching in 2023 could probably analyze a plot, but it takes someone like me—who’s been with the show since its beginnings—to really spot certain things I’ll be telling you about now.

Despite everything, I'm still proud of my RWBY recap. )

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Final Thoughts: Characters (Part I) | Table of ContentsRWBY Final Thoughts: Style
____________________


Hey, welcome back to the Final Thoughts for RWBY. Last time, we finished up the main cast, so now we’re gonna tackle everyone else.

Around fifty-ish travesties, give or take. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Final Thoughts: Story | Table of Contents | RWBY Final Thoughts: Characters (Part II)

____________________


Characterization was a major weak point of RWBY. You can tell after having been in the game as long as I have that Miles and Kerry just don’t have an equal amount of love for every character. They’re very protective of certain characters and very disdainful towards certain others, and it shows quite often.

Could've been iconic, instead it was demonic... )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Retrospective Part 2 | Table of Contents | RWBY Final Thoughts: Characters (Part 1)
____________________



The Vision


Once upon a time, back in the day, RWBY was this slapdash animesque show put together on the fly from all of the crazy, inspired things shooting out of Monty Oum’s brain and occasionally tinkered with by his two good pals Miles and Kerry.

But this is not a pleasant story and that's not how it ends. )

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY 2023 Retrospective (Part 1) | Table of Contents | RWBY Final Thoughts: Story
____________________


Continuing on from where we last left off, we're advancing on our journey of RWBY's most immortal moments, but this time the badge is one of disgrace.

While there were some sparks of quality here and there (mostly in Season 7) after RWBY took its swan dive, the vast majority of things RWBY gets remembered for post-Volume 5 are overwhelmingly negative, proofs that the show was just never going to be what it was meant to be, and never going to regain the quality and fun that it was once known for. 

I have twenty moments today that broke me and essentially spat in my face after all the time in my youth growing up that I spent faithfully watching this show and expecting greatness or at least goodness.

This is why we can't have nice things. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

Volume 9 Final Thoughts | Table of Contents | RWBY 2023 Retrospective (Part 2)
___________________


Back in June of ‘23, I posted a retrospective on RWBY, with the total point tallies and examinations of what they were saying about the show thus far. I also included a lit of my top 15 moments from the series up until that point, with a fond nostalgia for what I used to love about the show. I openly wondered whether such a list would be possible to make using material from Volumes 5-9.

So, with RWBY finally behind us, did I find more standout moments to applaud as I did when looking back over the first five volumes? Did I find anything worth returning to more than once for the sake of a spork?

Well, not many. I found ten in total and even then it was kind of a stretch. All eligible moments are sourced from any point later than the latest examples cited in the last post like this, since we already did one. The other twenty...well, let’s just call them the ultimate disappointments—twenty reasons not to watch RWBY at all. Those will be sourced from the whole show.

Some good? Maybe if you look hard enough. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY

Created by Monty Oum
Written by Monty Oum (V1-V3), Miles Luna, Kerry Shawcross, Kiersi Burkhart (V7-V9), Eddy Rivas (V7-V9)
Directed by Monty Oum (V1-V3), Kerry Shawcross
Music by Jeff Williams (V1-V8), Steve Goldshein (V1-V3), Alex Abraham (V1-V8), Casey Lee Williams (V8, V9), Martin Gonzales (V9)
Starring the voices of Lindsay Jones, Kara Eberle, Arryn Zech, and Barbara Dunkelman


Show’s over, guys. You witnessed the end with me. The slow and steady disintegrating of a titan and now we're standing amongst a pile of rubble.

But when it came time to write my final thoughts for the series as a whole, I just kept writing, and kept writing...it never stopped. So, fuck it, we might as well give it its own Table of Contents. Throughout this recap, I kept up a steady stream of supplied history and context, and I continued to do so here, so there was a lot to say.

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

58 – Volume 9 Finale | Table of Contents | RWBY: Final Thoughts
____________________


Welcome to my Final Thoughts on RWBY, Volume 9. Now, regardless of whether or not this ends up being the last volume of RWBY, it won’t be my last Final Thoughts on this show—I have one I’m cooking up for the show as a whole.

But before we get there, we have to observe the abomination that was Volume 9. And there is just so...so much.

Our last Final Thoughts for RWBY? Not quite. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

Alternate Title: The Most Ungraceful End

Last time we left off, Volume 9 had finally decided to stop playing around and just become flat-out unpleasant. Let's see if we can somehow top it in the volume's last two episodes.
The filler ends, clinging to a dim hope of a tenth season )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

Alternate Title: Paper Mario & Ruby Lets 'Em Have It

Other Alternate Title: I Think I'm Going To Be Sick

Last week's episode provided us a lot of questions. Will the cat be an ally? Will Jaune be the hero for once? Will Ruby make any actual move towards developing as a character? Was all of this necessary? Will there be a gay wave that finances RWBY enough to greenlight Volume 10? The answer to all of these questions is no, but unfortunately, I've got to spork anyway.

It won't come up until Episode 8, but please be aware that a
character commits suicide in this recap. That's your forewarning, and a more substantial one than Rooster Teeth gave, which was merely about 'distressing themes'. I mean, it has those too, plenty of them. You name it, Episode 8's got it. Excessive violence, trauma, manipulation, suicide, uncomfortably rape-y imagery... I'll put another warning ahead of the actual episode.
I will not forgive them for this. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

55 – Volume 9, Episodes 3 and 4 | Table of Contents | 57 – Volume 9, Episodes 7 and 8
____________________


Alternate Title: Rooster Teeth Play Their Hand

We are now halfway through the season as of this episode. I haven’t even started writing this and I already have a headache.

Last time...god, what the fuck happened last time? Oh, right, uh, acid trip character “development”. Well, let’s get into it.

I don't appreciate feeling used. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

I shamelessly pirated this, so the links I give may go dead if the videos are taken down. Just let me know if they fail to work.

V9E1, "A Place of Particular Concern"


We open on a blank screen with that female voice from the trailers.

This is the story of a show that had a lot of problems. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

RWBY Volume 9

Written by Miles Luna, Kerry Shawcross, Eddy Rivas, and Kiersi Burkhart
Directed by Kerry Shawcross, Connor Pickens, Dustin Matthews, and Paula Decanini
Produced under Rooster Teeth

Alternate Title: The One Where Everyone Stopped Caring

RWBY, Volume 9.

Originally, these recaps were posted concurrently with the volume's release in the first half of 2023. Those posts have been preserved, so you're welcome to browse them if you want my original reactions. Of course, this Table of Contents will instead have links to posts wherein these recaps are compiled into more complete forms and some edits are made here and there for the benefit of hindsight. And before that, we need a recap of events inbetween Volumes 8 and 9, so you know why this is probably going to be the last volume of RWBY, outright.

Regardless of what word from the company is. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

Volume 8 Final Thoughts (Part I) | Table of Contents | Volume 9

____________________


Welcome back to the Final Thoughts for Volume 8 of RWBY. We left off with the Characters slot about three-quarters done. Let’s finish that up now.

Here's the part where I tell you why Volume 10 isn't happening. )

 

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

52 – Volume 8, Episodes 11 and 12 | Table of Contents | Volume 8 Final Thoughts (Part I)

____________________


With this post, Volume 8 will be finished. All that will be left will be to do the Final Thoughts and Volume 9… However! There’s also my own advisory, which is that this post contains mentions and descriptions of violence and gore. Please be warned.

Also, this is one of my most image-heavy posts ever, since it’s a finale that’s, well…a nonstop mess. Constant action it would be a disservice to not relay to you—resulting in a post layered with over 50 of the fucking things. So here's a gif-less, text-only version for viewing accessibility.

Well. Let’s do this. There’s another epilepsy warning in front of this one.

I don't think I've ever been quite so disgusted with a show. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

52 – Volume 8, Episodes 11 and 12 | Table of Contents | Volume 8 Final Thoughts (Part I)

____________________


With this post, Volume 8 will be finished. All that will be left will be to do the Final Thoughts and Volume 9… However! There’s also my own advisory, which is that this post contains mentions and descriptions of violence and gore. Please be warned.

Also, this is one of my most image-heavy posts ever, since it’s a finale that’s, well…a nonstop mess. Constant action it would be a disservice to not relay to you—resulting in a post layered with over 50 of the fucking things. I might post a gif-less version later.

Well. Let’s do this. There’s another epilepsy warning in front of this one.

I don't think I've ever been quite so disgusted with a show. )
surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)

Somehow, Salem has been defeated, but we still have four more episodes. Well, she’s not dead, but her whole operation literally got blown to smithereens. And it will not be the last thing. We are again keeping the blue text because I am that maddeningly furious with what’s going on here.


Oh sure, let's just break ALL the rules! )

Profile

surgeworks: Striker, from Kohske's manga Gangsta. (Default)
surgeworks

March 2024

S M T W T F S
     12
345 678 9
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Aug. 16th, 2025 06:42 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios